In April 2022, Netflix (NASDAQ: NFLX) reported quarterly earnings of $3.53 per share, comfortably ahead of Wall Street’s $2.90 estimate. Yet its stock lost 36% of its value between April 15 and April 21, according to FactSet.
How does a company exceed earnings expectations and still lose more than a third of its market value?
The answer has much to do with what investors were buying in the first place. A stock’s price reflects expectations about a company’s future, and an earnings report can change those expectations in ways that aren’t immediately apparent from the headline numbers.
The good news may already be priced in
Leading up to an earnings announcement, investors position themselves according to what they believe a company will report.
Suppose a stock rallies 20% in the weeks before earnings. Analysts expect earnings per share (EPS) of $2, but many investors have already priced in the possibility of $2.30.
The company reports $2.15. Technically, it beat analyst estimates, but investors who anticipated something better may begin selling.
Traders often refer to this as a ‘sell-the-news’ event. Investors who bought ahead of an anticipated catalyst use the announcement as an opportunity to take profits, particularly when the results offer little reason to increase their expectations.
Guidance can matter more than earnings
Quarterly earnings tell investors how a business performed over the previous three months. Guidance offers management’s assessment of what comes next.
A company can deliver record profits while warning of slowing demand, rising operating costs or shrinking margins. Any of those developments could lead investors to reconsider what the business is worth.
Consider the case of Netflix again. Alongside its earnings beat, the company disclosed that it had lost 200,000 subscribers and expected to lose another 2 million during the following quarter.
For a business whose valuation depended heavily on subscriber growth, those figures were arguably more important than the earnings beat.
Not all earnings beats are created equal
It’s also worth examining how a company exceeded expectations.
Share repurchases, favorable tax adjustments and one-time gains can all contribute to higher earnings per share without necessarily reflecting stronger underlying demand for a company’s products.
A business that beats EPS estimates while missing revenue expectations may leave investors questioning the sustainability of its earnings growth.
What should traders look for?
Before taking a position following an earnings announcement, consider:
- How the stock performed leading into earnings.
- Whether management raised or lowered its guidance.
- Revenue growth, profit margins and other metrics important to the business.
- Management’s commentary during the earnings call.
- Whether buyers are stepping in or selling pressure continues.
Pay particular attention to that last point. A stock that cannot sustain a rally following seemingly favorable news may be telling traders something about investor expectations and sentiment.
An earnings beat is useful information, but it is only one piece of the report. Understanding what investors expected before the announcement, and how those expectations have changed since, can help explain why a strong quarter doesn’t always translate into a strong trading session.