A week before Anthropic (NASDAQ: ANT) made its Wall Street debut, Bloomberg reported that demand for the artificial intelligence company’s initial public offering was roughly six times the number of shares available.
It was an encouraging sign for investors hoping to profit from the company’s public debut. But what happened once Anthropic started trading illustrates why overwhelming demand for an IPO doesn’t necessarily translate into sustained buying on the open market.
What does oversubscribed mean?
An IPO is considered oversubscribed when investors request more shares than are available through the offering.
Suppose a company plans to sell 10 million shares, but prospective investors submit orders for 60 million. The offering would be six times oversubscribed.
That level of demand gives the company and its underwriters room to increase the offering price, sell additional shares or do both.
Anthropic did both.
The company initially planned to offer 825 million shares at between $70 and $78 apiece. It ultimately priced its IPO at $83 and increased the initial offering to 980 million shares.
What does this mean for potential shareholders?
Investors requesting shares ahead of an oversubscribed IPO may receive considerably fewer than they originally wanted.
Someone requesting 100 shares might receive 20, five or none at all. Allocations depend on the underwriters, participating brokerages and how shares are distributed among institutional and individual investors.
As the SEC explains, investment banks determine how much of an offering is made available to different groups of investors, often leaving individual investors competing for a limited supply.
Those who receive fewer shares than requested may choose to purchase more once public trading begins. That unmet demand can contribute to a sharp opening rally, commonly known as an ‘IPO pop’.
The important word there is can.
When demand meets reality
Anthropic opened at $111.50 on Nov. 19, approximately 34% above its $83 offering price. Shares briefly reached $115 before retreating to $97.17 by the closing bell.
Two investors could have bought into the same company that morning and walked away with very different experiences.
An investor who received shares at the offering price finished the session with a gain of roughly 17%. Someone who purchased shares at the opening price lost nearly 13%.
The distinction is that investors who expressed interest in Anthropic ahead of its IPO were doing so at a particular price. Their willingness to buy at $83 tells us relatively little about their willingness to buy at $115.
Meanwhile, investors who received IPO allocations may become sellers once trading begins, particularly those looking to capture a quick profit.
For traders, oversubscription is a useful measure of demand heading into an IPO, but it should never be mistaken for a measure of what the underlying business is worth.
There is a considerable difference between wanting to own a company and being willing to own it at any price. Anthropic’s first trading session offered a rather expensive illustration of that distinction.